Peter Haining has cast his net wide for this latest
collection of 24 comic tales of Fantasy. The earliest (Mediaeval Romance by Mark Twain) was first published in
1871 while the most recent (Wot the Eye Dont
See by Stan McMurtry) makes its début here.
The first
group, Flights of Fantasy: Stories of the Absurd,
is the most successful, and contains the pearls in this collection: Terry
Pratchetts Hollywood Chickens, a hysterical
take on Why (not How) the chicken crossed the road; Peter S Beagles
Lila the Werewolf as astute and vibrant as
when it was first written (1969); and Ray Bradburys hilarious account of
how award winning films are really made The Year the
Glop-Monster Won the Golden Lion at Cannes.
The
middle group, The Muddle Ages: Tales of Heroic
Times, mostly missed the mark for me. I loved Evan Hunters
Dream Damsel, whose smart damsel bests her dim
knight, but many of the other stories, while good, arent really
comic. And I cant help feeling that Haining allowed a love of
celebrity to influence his inclusion of the yawn-inducing The Creation According to Spike Milligan, and Peter
Sellers The Wastrel.
The final
group, Malice in Blunderland: Cases of Crime,
features many crime stories that are not actually comic, though
Haining fields the ironic get-out clause. Tom Sharpes wry
look at the classified ads Stirring the Pot, and
Stan McMurtrys aforementioned début about a clueless pub owner are
the most successful here.
Haining
deserves credit for bringing so many obscure tales blinking sheepishly into the
light of day. Unfortunately, time is not kind to comedy, and some simply
dont travel well out of context. But stories that didnt tickle my
funny bone may appeal to other readers. And the Pratchett, Beagle, and Bradbury
contributions alone are worth the price of this collection.
Starburst
rating: 7 / 10
Barbara Davies
|